Showing posts with label jury. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jury. Show all posts

2009-05-23

Henan High Court President Defends Experiments with People's Assessors System

河南高院院长:死刑二审"征求意见"并非"民意审判"

Xinhua News, 2009-05-18

In an interview, Zhang Liyong, president of the Henan Province High Court, defended the court's recent experiments with including “people's representatives” in death penalty review cases. Zhang said the practice allows the court to better understand “local popular sentiment” but in no way constitutes “trial by public opinion.” He remarked that the “Western jury system,” though effective in preventing corruption, is “unsuitable to Chinese conditions,” and local changes to and expansion of the People's Assessor system are not an indigenization of the jury system. Zhang also defended the legality of the court's experiments, including in the inclusion of sentencing arguments in pre-verdict court hearings, against suggestions they contradict China's procedural laws.

2009-05-15

Henan Local Court Adopts Sentencing Advice from Student Representatives

郑州金水区法院尝试群众陪审 大学生意见被采纳

Xinhua News, 2009-05-13

In an effort to better grasp “public opinion” and “promote judicial fairness,” the Jinshui District (Zhengzhou, Henan Province) Juvenile Court invited over 200 local university students to observe the trial of two juvenile defendants accused of robbery. The court also solicited “conviction and sentencing advice” from six student representatives and reportedly adopted their advice in giving the defendants “lenient” sentences of three years and one and a half years fixed term imprisonment, respectively. In later interviews, the vice-chief judge of the juvenile court and a local law professor both disagreed with “some people who think inviting college students [to participate] in panel hearings on cases is unsuitable” and affirmed the positive role students could play in judicial proceedings.

2009-05-05

Shanxi High Court Includes “Citizen Representatives'” Opinions in Appeal Hearings

陕西高院出新规 公民代表旁听庭审可发言

Xinhua News, 2009-05-05

In order to “further judicial open democracy and achieve judicial fairness by closely relying on the supervision and support of the masses,” the Shanxi Province High Court is asking “citizen representatives”—who were recruited to observe public appeal hearings—to offer orally their opinions on the case before them to justices after the “debate” part of the hearing and before the defendant's final statement. Reactions to the inclusion of the opinions are mixed. The president of the province's high court believes it “undoubtedly conforms with criminal justice policy and the spirit of the law,” while a county school teacher who served as a citizen representative gained legal knowledge from the experience and feels such participation can make trials more open and fair. A Xian (Shanxi Province) lawyer worried, however, that the new procedure will influence the seriousness and professionalism of the justice system.

2009-04-26

“Citizen Representatives” Speak at Shanxi High Court Criminal Appeal Hearing

陕西:公民代表在法庭上有了裁判发言权 全国首次

Xinhua News, 2009-04-26

At the appeal hearing of He Xiaoguo and Zhao Qiang, earlier sentenced to death and 15 years imprisonment for robbing, killing and burning the body of a local railway employee, the Shanxi High Court's Second Criminal Court arranged for five “citizen representatives”—two People's Congress delegates, two Political Consultative Conference members and a school teacher, according to another article—to offer their opinions on how the court should adjudicate the case. The representatives' participation was meant “to increase the degree of recognition among the victim's family and society that the case was justly adjudicated and to urge the defendants to admit their crimes and obey the law,” as well as to allow the court to “fully grasp the opinion of the masses about this case.”

2009-04-15

People's Assessor (Jury) System to Expand by 15,000 Participants in 2009

中国人民陪审员今年将超过7万人

Xinhua News, 2009-04-14

To better implement “judicial democracy” and allow for greater popular participation in judicial procedures, the Supreme People's Court issued a circular outlining the expansion of the People's Assessor System by over 25%, from 55,681 jurors to more than 70,000, by later this year. The new system requires intermediate and grassroots-level courts to hold at least two forums each year to hear opinions and advice from local jurors. Jurors are to serve as a bridge between the courts and the masses, reflecting genuine—because they “come from the masses, are close to the masses and serve the masses”—public sentiments to the court and spreading legal knowledge among the people.

2009-04-10

Henan High Court Uses People's Assessors (Jurors) in Capital Case Review

河南省高院首次尝试“陪审团”参与死刑二审

Xinhua News, 2009-04-10

The presiding judge of the Henan Supreme Court's First Criminal Court, Pan Jialing, welcomed the presence of eight “National People's Congress deputies, CPPCC members, cadres and representatives of the masses” for the court's second hearing and review of a death penalty. He explained that as People's Assessors (jurors) they were “well versed in local circumstances and had the right to speak about whether the criminal should be sentenced to death. Their advice . . . will guarantee that death sentences have the optimal legal and social impacts.” Pan also said he believes “assessors” [the same Chinese term is used to translate “jury”] should instead be called “reviewers” to more accurately reflect their dual functions of “supervising judge's words, deeds, demeanor and sentencing work-style, in addition to reflecting public sentiment.”

2009-04-06

Local Fuzhou Court Explores People's Assessor System

福州鼓楼区法院:人民陪审员选任“专家化”

Xinhua News, 2009-04-05

In addition to soliciting applications from “talented people in all professional fields” to serve in the local People's Assessor (Jury) System—53 out of 637 applicants have been selected since 2006—the Gulou District Court in Fuzhou, Fujian Province, has released provisional regulations detailing the rights and obligations of assessor. Those rights include the “independent exercise of voting rights,” “right to request a case be handed on to a judicial committee for discussion,” and the “right for juror's dissenting opinions in collegiate bench-decided cases to be included in court notes.”