2009-06-13

Kunming Police Release Investigation Results in “Primary School Prostitution Case”

[小学女生卖淫案]警方认定存在卖淫行为

Beijing News, 2009-06-10

Nearly three months after the overnight detention and interrogation of two primary school female students, their mother and her domestic partner on suspicion of prostitution, Kunming (Yunnan Province) police and procuracy officials issued the results of their investigation: the domestic partner, Liu Shihua, and mother, Zhang Anfen, “intentionally plotted, engaged in deception, violently resisted the law, deceived the media, and misled the masses in creating a heinously influential incident.” Kunming prosecutors have charged the two with criminally “sheltering prostitution”—a charge related to Liu's 17-year-old daughter “Chen Yan,” not Zhang's two daughters—and are holding Liu in criminal detention while Zhang has been released on bail.

The so-called “3.16” (16 March, 2009) incident involved two community patrolmen—typically laid-off employees of defunct state enterprises hired to assist local police, but not official public security personnel—subduing by force participants in what they believed to be a prostitution ring. After police at the local public security station released Liu, Zhang and her two daughters the next day due to a lack of evidence, Liu and Zhang had medical examiners at a local hospital document their injuries and confirm that Zhang's daughters' were virgins. They also told local media they were unjustly accused, tortured while in detention and seeking damages from the police. The investigation report alleges that the patrolmen had indeed witnessed “Chen Yan” soliciting—she had been fined 1,300RMB in October 2008 for prostitution—but Liu and Zhang then had her switch clothes with Zhang's eldest daughter to confuse police. According to police and prosecutors, none of the suspects were tortured during interrogation and their injuries resulted from the scuffle with the community patrolmen, who have since been dismissed and “dealt with.”

2009-06-11

Local Beijing Court Experiments with Witness Testimony at Trials

北京探索“关键证人”出庭作证机制

Xinhua New, 2009-06-11

Since early 2008, the Beijing Xicheng District Procuratorate, in coordination with the Xicheng District Court, has been experimenting with having “key” witnesses in “complex and difficult to solve cases” appear in court to give their testimony firsthand during trial. To date, twenty-three witnesses have appeared in twelve different cases—primarily cases in which defendants refuse to admit their crimes or written testimony submitted by witnesses, including police investigators and experts, is contradictory. Because China's criminal procedure law fails to clearly prescribe witnesses' duty to obey court subpoenas, Xicheng prosecutors must “convince” witnesses—often worried about their personal and financial safety, as well as job security—to appear in court. In part to allay those worries, the procuratorate gives “economic compensation” to covers witnesses' “transportation, food and lodging costs and lost wages.” Prosecutors are also “supposed to give assistance” to the defense in producing (“inviting”) their own trial witnesses as part of the principle of arms (“principle of prosecution and defense equality”).

2009-06-09

Legal Aid Cases Increasing by 30% per Year

五年来我国办理法律援助案件数量以每年30%的幅度递增

Xinhua News, 2009-06-09

At the fifth annual “National Legal Aid Work Conference,” Minister of Justice Wu Aiying said the number of cases handled by legal aid organizations has been increasing by 30% per year since 2004. Among the many areas of legal aid she singled out for increased focus, Wu noted the need to “earnestly handle” criminal defense, especially in cases involving the physically handicapped, juveniles and those potentially facing capital punishment. Legal aid organizations should, “according to law, offer defense and representation to economically disadvantaged parties to criminal cases, and uphold the procedural rights of criminal suspects, criminal defendants, and victims.” According to the Ministry of Justice, China currently has 3,268 legal aid organizations at the county-level and above and 55,708 lower-level legal aid stations—all manned by a total of only 12,778 “legal aid organization staff.”


Special Funds Established for Legal Aid in Impoverished Areas

我国有19个省区市建立了省级财政法律援助专项资金

Xinhua News, 2009-06-09

According to the Ministry of Justice, 19 provinces have allocated special funds in their provincial budgets to support, along with central government funds, legal aid in impoverished areas. Since 2004, government budgeting for legal aid has increased at an average annual rate of 30%. 88% of legal aid funding comes directly from state coffers; the remainder coming from the China Legal Aid Foundation, local legal aid foundations, and other public fundraising sources.

2009-06-06

Additional Developments in Dandong County Stabbing (Deng Yuqiao) Case

邓玉娇已被起诉至巴东县法院

Caijing Online, 2009-05-06

Nearly four weeks after 22-year-old karaoke center waitress Deng Yuqiao stabbed two Dandong County (Hubei Province) government officials—killing one—in alleged self-defense, new case developments continue to attract national attention. After local police issued their official investigation report alleging Deng used “undue defense” (excessive force), the Dandong County Procuratorate officially indicted Deng on criminal charges of “intentional harm.” Prosecutors also cited her acts of self-defense and voluntary surrender to police as mitigating circumstances that allow “a lighter or mitigated punishment or an exemption from punishment.” The charges were filed with the basic-level county court, not an intermediate court as typically required in cases where the sentence could be life imprisonment or death, as is statutorily allowed for intentional harm.

Huang Dezhi, the surviving local official injured by Deng, is currently in administrative police detention—in effect signaling he will not be criminally prosecuted, after being expelled from the Communist Party and his township government positions by the local Party discipline inspection committee. The case has stirred reflection on Chinese attitudes toward rape and self-defense; in a Southern Weekend op-ed, China University of Politics and Law professor Xiao Han critiques traditional beliefs in a-life-for-a-life and the blind valuation of human life over more abstract ideals of dignity and honor as reasons why so many Chinese people disagree with the right to unlimited force in defending against rape that Article 20 of the China's Criminal Code so clearly bestows.

2009-06-05

Defense Attorneys Reflect on 1st Anniversary of Amended Law on Lawyers

律师法实施一周年 律师谈律师法与执业权利保障

Xinhua News, 2009-06-05

In a recent interview, two criminal defense lawyers, Liu Hai and Yi Shenghua, with the Yingke Beijing law firm, spoke about the 2008-amended Law on Lawyers from the angle of lawyers' professional safeguards. Liu affirmed the progress the law had made in guaranteeing lawyers' right to meet with clients and access case files, although he admitted that those rights “still come under some restrictions.” Yi added that “in some areas” “some judicial organs” have consciously failed to implement the law, pointing to its contradictions with parts of the Criminal Procedure Law and even arguing that the Law on Lawyers is just for you lawyers and does not concern them. To solve those problems they urged amending the Criminal Procedure Law and, more importantly, passing implementing rules and regulations that clearly protect lawyers' professional rights and strictly punish any and all infringements of those rights.

2009-06-04

“A Judicial Conundrum: The Mentally Ill Who Have Killed”

司法之困:那些犯下命案的精神病人

Southern Weekend, 2009-06-04

An investigative article explores the fate of the violently mentally ill in China's criminal justice system. Forensic psychiatrics too often succumb to public pressure calling for “a life for a life” and determine mentally ill suspects to have partial or diminished criminal responsibility, both of which qualify them for criminal punishments, including death. Doctors even admit to an unspoken rule: if the victim is related to the suspect, they can be declared criminally incompetent, if not, they are declared to have diminished criminal responsibility. Suspects typically undergo multiple psychiatric evaluations, each with varying determinations, leaving the court—subject to the same public pressure—to chose one that fits their judgment. The mentally ill are thus incarcerated with the general prison population and receive only limited, if any, psychiatric medical care, leaving themselves and their fellow inmates subject to continued dangers.

Lawyer's Political Responsibilities Stressed in Law Firm Party Secretary Training

“特殊堡垒”的特别培训 律师事务所党支书纳入培训体系

Southern Weekend, 2009-06-04

In last month's training sessions held by the Ministry of Justice for the Communist Party secretaries of private law firm's Party cells training, official speakers stressed lawyers' role as “legal workers” whose “professional freedoms have definite limits, especially in mass incident cases and major sensitive cases, where lawyers' grasp of political orientation is extremely important.” Deputy Minister of Justice Zhao Dacheng asserted that “lawyers' foremost political responsibility is to fully implement the Center's “Guaranteeing Stability” policy and maintain social harmony and stability.” Speakers also reportedly criticized lawyers' who aided Tibetans suspected of participating in last year's disturbances, saying the lawyers' “had demonstrated failings in their political consciousness.”

2009-06-01

Shanghai Issues New Restrictions on Prosecutor Interactions with Defense Lawyers

上海出台规定规范检察官和律师交往行为

Caijing Online, 2009-06-01

The Shanghai Procuratorate issued provisional regulations governing the interactions of procuratorate officials with lawyers involved in ongoing cases. In addition to proscribing a long list of acts prosecutors themselves may not engage in—from revealing internal procuracy information to borrowing lawyers' communication devices—prosecutors immediate relatives are also banned from a host of activities involving plaintiffs and their lawyers. Prominent lawyers and legal scholars do not, however, believe the new regulations will effectively combat prosecutorial abuse and corruption, both of which they identify as rooted in problems of professional self-discipline in the current criminal justice system.

History and Current State of China's Juvenile Courts

我国少年法庭25年艰辛探索之路

Xinhua News, 2009-06-01

A series of news reports explores the history and development of juvenile court divisions in China, from the nation's first such division established in Shanghai in 1984 to the current 2,219 spread throughout the country. Those 2,219 courts reportedly have 7,018 juvenile judges serving in either independent juvenile divisions of their parent courts or in fixed juvenile collegiate panels under the courts' criminal divisions. Not only cases involving juveniles as criminal defendants but also cases where the protection of minors' rights are at stake come under the juvenile courts' jurisdiction. Wang Shengjun, president of the Supreme People's Court, noting the “youthening” trend in Chinese criminal activity, has recently praised the juvenile courts and called for their strengthening and continued reform.