2009-04-29

Supreme Court to Revise Judicial Interpretation on Sentence Reduction and Parole

最高法:办理减刑假释案件司法解释年内修订施行

Xinhua News, 2009-04-29

Jiang Bixin, vice-president of the Supreme People's Court, explained that the revised judicial interpretation on sentence reduction and parole—to be issued this year—will emphasize following the “temper justice with mercy criminal policy.” In adjudicating sentence reduction and parole cases, courts will consider not just an inmate's manifestations of rehabilitation but also the “nature, circumstances, subjective malice and reason behind the crime, as well as other factors.” Jiang clearly stated that despite current low parole rates, courts will not “mechanically” pursue increased rates but instead will “persist in proceeding from actual conditions and gradual push on with parole work in ways that suit local conditions.”

2009-04-26

Law Firm Offers Free Counsel to Indigent Defendants Who Surrender to Authorities

黑龙江首家投案自首法律机构成立 投案自首免律师费

Xinhua News, 2009-04-26

The Dagong Law Firm in Heilongjiang Province has established the “Heilongjiang Dagong Voluntary Surrender Legal Service Center” to provide free defense counsel for criminal suspects with “economic difficulties” who voluntarily surrender to the police or procuratorial organs investigating them. Center employees will conduct phone consultations for suspects and explain the relevant “laws, regulations and policies on leniency, reduced sentences and exemptions from punishments” and accompany them to police or procuracy offices to surrender.

“Citizen Representatives” Speak at Shanxi High Court Criminal Appeal Hearing

陕西:公民代表在法庭上有了裁判发言权 全国首次

Xinhua News, 2009-04-26

At the appeal hearing of He Xiaoguo and Zhao Qiang, earlier sentenced to death and 15 years imprisonment for robbing, killing and burning the body of a local railway employee, the Shanxi High Court's Second Criminal Court arranged for five “citizen representatives”—two People's Congress delegates, two Political Consultative Conference members and a school teacher, according to another article—to offer their opinions on how the court should adjudicate the case. The representatives' participation was meant “to increase the degree of recognition among the victim's family and society that the case was justly adjudicated and to urge the defendants to admit their crimes and obey the law,” as well as to allow the court to “fully grasp the opinion of the masses about this case.”

Jiangxi Includes Legal Aid in Livelihood Project and Allocates 10 Million RMB

赣法律援助列入民生工程 投千万助困难群体打官司

Xinhua News, 2009-04-26

To solve the problem of “vulnerable groups not being able to hire a lawyer or sue in court,” Jiangxi Province has included legal aid among its “people's livelihood projects.” The province has lowered the monthly income eligibility threshold for free legal aid to 1.5 times the local “minimum standard of living” and 2 times the standard for the handicapped, elderly, women, juveniles and migrant workers. A newly issued legal aid “implementation plan” also requires the number cases accepted by legal aid organizations to increase by over 40% this year to 18,000 and other legal services—including consultation and document drafting—to increase by over 50% to 150,000 instances.

2009-04-23

“First Death Penalty in the Securities Industry” Upheld in Final Judgment

“证券界死刑第一人”终审死刑

Beijing News, 2009-04-23

The Beijing High Court upheld a lower court's death sentence for Yang Yanming, a former securities company CEO, convicted of corruption. Yang's first conviction in 2005 had been overturned on appeal by the High Court, which ordered the case retried. At his second appeal, Yang explained that he used the 69 million RMB he is accused of embezzling to bribe various “work groups and individuals” but refused to divulge who he distributed the money to. Public discussions about the case have focused on whether Yang could or should be spared death if he reveals who accepted his bribes, with law professor Liu Mingxiang arguing he might still face capital punishment even if he divulges all. Yang's sentence still awaits final review by the Supreme People's Court.

2009-04-22

Shanxi Province Loosens Restrictions on Juvenile Sentence Reductions and Parole

山西:放宽对未成年犯的减刑、假释条件

Xinhua News, 2009-04-22

In coordination with the newly-established “Juvenile Criminal Education, Exhortation and Rescue Base,” the Taiyan (Shanxi) Intermediate Court signed an agreement with the Shanxi Provincial Juvenile Reformatory to increase juvenile offenders' opportunities for sentence reductions and parole. Juveniles serving sentences of over one year will be able to apply yearly for sentence reductions of three months to three years based on displays of contrition and meritorious service.


Criminal Defamation Cases Stir Controversy and Demands for Reform

“吴保全案”提起审判监督程序 进入再审过程

Xinhua News, 2009-04-21

Several recent criminal defamation cases have generated nation-wide media attention and sharp critique from legal scholars. In one case, Wu Baoquan, an Inner Mongolia native living in Qingdao, wrote an internet post describing the abusive land expropriation policies local officials had forced on his acquaintance and fellow villagers in Eerduosi City, Inner Mongolia. Police officers from Eerduosi arrested Wu and sentenced him to 10 days of administrative detention. After his release, Wu posted more writings on the incident and was again detained by Eerduosi police and prosecuted on criminal charges of “defaming the government.” A grass-roots level court sentenced Wu to one year imprisonment; he appealed, and the city's intermediate court sent the case back for retrial, explaining the “facts are not clear.” In the retrial, Wu was again found guilty and his sentence increased to two years for “not showing contrition while released on bail” and working in tandem with petitioning villagers. On 17 April, the Eerduosi Intermediate Court upheld Wu's two year prison sentence.

In another case still pending, Deng Yonggu, an agricultural service center employee in Pengxi County, Sichuan Province, posted a blog accusing four local cadres of illegal actions, listing their cell phone numbers and calling them “scum.” Local police later arrested Deng on charges of defamation and brought him to trial in county court on 20 April 2009. Court arguments focused on why the case required state prosecutors to bring criminal charges instead of the “victims” simply suing in civil court, with prosecutors arguing that Deng's post qualified as criminal defamation under the criminal law's “seriously endangers social stability and national interests” proviso.

Two editorials by legal commentators question the motives and methods of local officials in the cases and call for legislative change. Writing in the Beijing News, Wang Gangqiao, suggests the National People's Congress remove the above proviso from the article on defamation or at least exercise their legislative right to interpret the law and restrict the abusive use of the proviso. Wei Wenbiao's article in the Guangming Daily stresses Chinese citizens' constitutional right to offer critique and advice to the government. He also pushes for increased judicial independence—partly to be achieved with direct central funding of and hiring power over local courts—to protect the legal system from becoming a retributive tool in the hands of “a few local governments and officials.”

2009-04-20

15 Unnatural Detention Center Deaths Reported This Year

高检院:今年接到在押者非正常死亡报告15名

Xinhua News, 2009-04-20

In a recent TV and telephone conference, the Supreme People's Procuratorate “leaked” that it has received reports of 15 detention center deaths due to unnatural causes so far this year. A spokesperson from the Procuratorate's Prison Inspection Office blamed the deaths on both insufficient public security bureau supervision and weak oversight from the procuracy. Current efforts to establish information and surveillance cyber-networks in prisons directly linked to local procuratorate offices are aimed at preventing similar deaths.

Leading Communist Party Journal Calls for Limiting Pre-Trial Detention

学习时报:改革审前羁押率太高的局面势在必行

Xinhua News, 2009-04-20

The Central Party School's flagship publication, Study Times, printed an article by Liu Renwen, a researcher with the Chinese Academy of Social Science, criticizing the high rate of pre-trial detention in China's criminal justice system and calling for legislative and administrative reform. Liu points out the problems with excessive pre-trial detention—detention center overcrowding, unnecessary waste of state resource, endangerment of suspects' human rights and contradictions with the presumption of innocence. For solutions, he calls for adapting foreign legal systems' strict time limits on police custody, greater improvement and use of bail pending trial and reform and implementation of the residential surveillance system.

Over 85% of Defendants in “Reconciled Criminal Cases” Get Non-Prison Sentences

山东超过85%的刑事和解案件被告人被判处非监禁刑

Xinhua News, 2009-04-20

As an example of how the People's Courts are helping “construct a harmonious society” and “effectively defusing social contradictions,” the Shandong Province High Court released statistics showing that over 85% of defendants in “reconciled criminal cases” receive sentences of probation, court supervision or monetary fines, not imprisonment. Types of “reconciliation” include court-mediated, self-mediated and trustee-mediated with victims typically receiving financial compensation from defendants; over 40% of such cases involved either traffic accidents or intentional injury. To qualify for lighter, non-prison sentences, crimes must be “minor” and defendants must display a “relatively good attitude in admitting guilt,” “actively display contrition” and “reach an understanding with the victim(s).”